It's Not Really About The Milk

topic posted Mon, June 23, 2008 - 11:19 AM by  Duracell
"You won't "get it" at first. At first it's all about technique, and position, and time, and swallowing, and soreness, and feeling as if your whole world has narrowed to Feeding The Baby. Those of us who have enjoyed nursing our children are on the other side of a great emotional gulf from you. We can't explain it, we can only try to help you across the bridge, to where you can see for yourself. If you stay caught up in this as a feeding method, you may never get all the way across the bridge. But oh, the view from the other side!

Those of us who "got it" wouldn't feel guilty if we were prevented from nursing our next child. We'd feel anguished. "Guilt" means you didn't do something for someone else that you "should" have done whether or not you enjoyed it yourself. "Anguish" means great pain and grief, as if you've had a piece of yourself torn away.

Imagine moving by shifting your weight left, moving your right leg forward, knee slightly bent at first but gradually straightening, right heel landing as you rise on the ball of your left foot, left arm forward in reverse synchrony with your right as it moves back, then performing a mirror image of the whole process for the next step. Not fun, not easy, not graceful, not something you want to keep working at. But imagine the ease and pleasure of simply... walking. Now imagine someone telling you that you have to give it up. Guilt? Or anguish?

I wish I could convey to you the simple, thought-less, vast, delicious pleasure of nursing my children. Once I "got it," I didn't "feed" them, didn't worry about intervals, didn't hold back. We nursed when they wanted and when I wanted - even just to keep them quiet while I was on the phone. At night, nursing was a quiet mending of the day's disorders. Oh, not always, but as someone said, "Of course there's an inconvenience to nursing. But there's an inconvenience to being a mother." Breastfeeding was a fundamental, essential connection for us, and made everything else - from newborn diapers to two-year-old tantrums - far, far simpler. Then there's the ego-building experience of being the perfect center of another person's universe.

Can you achieve the same bond through bottle-feeding? No. Remember that a breastfeeding mother is in a specific hormonal state. Her whole body responds to her baby in a way that a bottle-feeding mother's or a baby-sitter's or a father's cannot. Her infant receives all his calories in a full-bodied, full-mouthed, skin-on-skin embrace, always from his beloved mother. Her older child comes to her to have growing pains of all kinds soothed simply in a way unique to breastfeeding.

Breastfeeding is a newborn's first relationship, designed to continue throughout a child's early years. As a culture, we tell ourselves - without evidence - that the absence of this fundamental human relationship has no longterm implications for mother or child or family or society.
I have enjoyed our children at every stage so far - and they are now adults. Their father and I felt as if we did no real parenting after the first ten years or so; we sat back and enjoyed them. This is unusual in America today. Is it partly related to our start in a long, luxurious breastfeeding relationship? I think so. And like every woman who has reached the other side of the bridge, I hope I can extend a hand back to help you across. The view is irreplaceable!"

©2008 Diane Wiessinger, MS, IBCLC www.normalfed.com
posted by:
Duracell
SF Bay Area
  • Re: It's Not Really About The Milk

    Mon, June 23, 2008 - 1:43 PM
    What a beautifully written article! Thank you for the post. I'm so glad that I've made it across too. For the first 8-10 weeks I thought I was never going to make it, but I did! Still, there's no sugar coating the fact that to make breastfeeding work, you have to really commit to a 6-10 hour a day nursable state of being. I loved that quote about "having children is inconvenient too." I do not grudge my child the time she takes. As she has gotten older I am now shocked to see how much and how fast the time has slid by us.

    We're (ped approved, gestational age six months) starting solids next week. I think. Maybe. If I can bring myself to it. I've always loved feeling useful, and this nursing thing has got to be the most useful thing my body has ever accomplished for anyone. But still, food has got to happen sometime, right? Rice, sweet potato, avocado, tears, check. The future, up to and including Seventh grade, here we come!
  • Re: It's Not Really About The Milk

    Mon, June 23, 2008 - 5:52 PM
    That was great! I had that choked up feeling of being on the verge of tears... so touching. Thank you for sharing that article!
    • Re: It's Not Really About The Milk

      Mon, June 23, 2008 - 8:30 PM
      it is articles like these that i am keeping in my happy place to mentally go to when my little one is melting down and needing boob in a very public place and i just pop it out and feed her knowing it is best for both of us while i am sure and more than aware that there are at least a few disapproving looks coming our way...

      i was in a target in austin a while back passing through the diaper aisle and there in the aisle perched on the bottom shelf sat a mama with her older child talking while she breastfed her baby and it was such a beautifully normal sight for me i just smiled and kept shopping but a couple of aisles down there were these young women who were discussing how gross it was that this mama was breastfeeding her baby all in public....that pissed me off so i popped out my boob and started feeding my girl in her sling and made a point of walking right by them while she was eating.

      so there. that shut them up.
      • Re: It's Not Really About The Milk

        Mon, June 23, 2008 - 8:54 PM
        "a couple of aisles down there were these young women who were discussing how gross it was that this mama was breastfeeding her baby all in public."

        that makes me so sad. for so many reasons.



        but i really enjoyed that article as well. thanks for sharing it karen.
  • Re: It's Not Really About The Milk

    Tue, June 24, 2008 - 5:17 AM
    just lovely.
    • Re: It's Not Really About The Milk

      Tue, June 24, 2008 - 7:52 AM
      thank you very much. i will certainly use that site as yet another resource. it's so nice to have this "village" of women to glean from, having no mother nor sisters of my own, and being the first of my friends to have a baby. highly appreciated.

      • Re: It's Not Really About The Milk

        Sat, June 28, 2008 - 2:57 PM
        yes !! very encouraging too. thanks duracell. =)
        • Re: It's Not Really About The Milk

          Mon, June 30, 2008 - 12:18 AM
          I had a very positive experience this week I'd like to share. I had to take my friend to surgery to get a sewing machine needle chunk removed from her fingertip (totally ewww) and she needed a driver and general babysitter because Valium tends to make you loopy. So we got to the office and got groggy Katie all checked in and I was concerned about being able to just wait in the waiting room the whole time with Anthea, but the receptionist had three kids of her own and said that there was no problem at all with us staying and that I was welcome to nurse. Anthea had a blowout diaper, no sweat, she urped on the carpet, peachy, she whined and whimpered because she's teething, the nurse cooed at her. We finally settled in to some serious nursing after we'd been there an hour or so (Katie'd really stuck herself good) and the door from the hall pops open and in comes this woman in her mid fifties or so. I can't nurse Anthea with any kind of cover, she won't have it at any price, and I wasn't particularly hanging all out or anything, but I'm obviously nursing, and I thought," oh well, hopefully she's not the easily offended type." She briskly marched in and settled her business with the receptionist and swooped back out while remarking "I'm SO GLAD to see you nursing your baby. Good work, and you're doing what's best for both of you, BRAVO!"

          It was so nice to hear such positivity about NIP from a stranger when usually embarrassed eye averted silence is about as positive as it gets from anyone who's not also currently a nursing mommy.

          And to top it all off, Katie got to take her needle home as a souvenir! BLEAGH!!!
          • Re: It's Not Really About The Milk

            Mon, June 30, 2008 - 8:59 AM
            totally great story! you just never know how people (even women, which surprises me) are going to react. what i've noticed from talking to all ages of ladies is that it is a generational thing, too. at some time periods it wasn't supported and was actually frowned upon ("that's what 'poor' people do"), which seems so unbelievable to me.
  • Re: It's Not Really About The Milk

    Thu, July 3, 2008 - 10:02 AM
    i read this aloud to DH and i started to cry! so i reposted it to my myspace heh :D
    thank you so much for sharing! there are lots of other good stories on that website as well! thank you so much!

Recent topics in "Breastfeeding"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
worried 7 Yesterday, 6:25 PM
Protest at H&M in Vancouver Kit Kat 4 Yesterday, 2:57 PM
tyra banks tears down extended breastfeeders ix-chel 21 August 18, 2008
Pop On, Pop Off--what is this about? offlineFreya 6 August 14, 2008